We’ve Got it All Wrong


Let me start by saying that I know that some educators out there will say “This is easy for you to say.  You’re in an “A-rated” school and you’re in an affluent community.”

And those people would be correct.  It is easy for me to say.  That’s the point.

Because it is easy for me to say, I need to say that school grades based on a single test measure do not and will never accurately portray the true value of a school.  There have been many opponents to standardized testing in the past but those of us who have benefitted from these assessments and the subsequent school ratings have to stand up for our colleagues in the education field.  Because while my school staff and community will be celebrating how well we performed, there are friends of mine throughout education who are crushed right now.  Devastated because the perception of their school will change because of a single letter grade.

This is wrong on so many levels.

Florida released school grades a few days ago.  This time the scores are based on the two-year comparison of the FSA (Florida Standards Assessments) that was first implemented last year.  These school grades are the first “official” grade to be given with our new assessments.  The school grades that were released for the previous year were termed “Informational Baseline” with the preposed caveat that there were no consequences for those grades (I will get back to that in a moment).

So the grades came out and my school is “A-rated” once again.  But what does that mean? I honestly don’t feel that this tells anywhere near the complete story of what my school is.  Walk through our halls, talk to our students and staff, ask the community.  I believe you will hear about a school filled with love, happiness, a desire to help all students, and individuals seeking to innovate so that our students are always exposed to the best possible practices, strategies and technologies that help make their lives better.

And I believe that most schools are filled with the same love and happiness, the same desire to do whatever it takes for kids.  But, unfortunately, so many schools are living under the fear of the almighty school grade.  Numerous schools are forced to deliver curriculum and strategies designed specifically to raise test scores.  And yes they are forced, because there is always a consequence for school grades, whether the State says so or not.  The biggest consequence is public perception.  We are so conditioned to believe in school grades based off of a test that only measures how well students do on the FSA in English Language Arts, Math, and Science (for elementary schools).  Schools that don’t perform well on these accountability measures aren’t always afforded the opportunities to innovate and try new ideas like those of us who do perform well.

I have been talking to educator friends of mine, both teachers and principals, from different schools these past few days.  Some are so distraught because their school grade “dropped”.  One of my friends, who is one of the best teachers that I have ever met, said “Does this really mean that from last year to this year we just sat around and did nothing to educate our kids?  We still have the same passionate and dedicated teachers.”  All of our schools are filled with caring, compassionate educators who are relentless in their pursuit of helping make kids’ lives better.  All of our schools have students who deserve the best each day.

This madness needs to stop.  We need the general public to wake up and realize that we are demoralizing entire school communities and reducing their efforts to nothing by placing a grade on them.  While some of us have freedom and are highly regarded because of these grades, there are so many more educators who don’t have that opportunity.  We need everyone to talk about this and spread the word.  Our schools are so much more than a letter grade.






5 thoughts on “We’ve Got it All Wrong

  1. Keith, I completely agree. As a teacher it was disheartening to hear these types of things from the public, and even more so from other teachers in the building. I have just been appointed as an administrator, and I am constantly thinking about ways to move the focus to learning and joy instead of numbers and grades. Suggestions?

    1. The key for me has been to not make school about the standardized tests or the grades. We don’t focus on them at all school-wide. No pep rallies, no pressure from me onto teachers or students. Highlight what really should be valued – Tweet about it, blog about it, speak about it in all conversations.

  2. I am so lucky to work with you KP who motivates teachers to teach and love kids and not worry about scores. And look at what happens we succeed. So so blessed!

  3. I personally have responded to the concerns of parents from one of our schools. They were ready and close to pulling their child out of a school that they recently moved here for because it dropped a grade .
    A grade that has so many factors other than what really goes in in the classroom on a daily basis .
    On the positive this parent posted her concerns on social media and there were numerous , incredible responses and explanations .
    I live in the area and I am confident that all of our schools are fabulous and the children are loved and nurtured as much as previously , even with going down by one point .
    Many BROWARD county parents were helpful and responded with the utmost respect and trust in that school.
    By the end of the posts the initial parent thanked everyone and said she had made her decision . They were staying with the school they came here for .
    So in essence it was heartwarming as a teacher and a parent in this community to see the help this new family received and the respect for our schools.
    Mr Peters is my principal and the truth is he does not focus on the scores . His focus is on the day to day activities , faces in the hallway and most important on the love for not just teaching but motivating young people to believe in their selves along with our staff .
    I truly believe that it is not about the money , or the scores but the buy into why we do what we do , love for helping people be the best they can .
    What is most important is that everyone is there as a team , to achieve successful , confident , happy and motivated children who are our future .

  4. Thank you for this. It kills me when I hear that people want to pull their child from our school based on it’s grade (D). Our school is not defined by this letter. Walk through the halls, sit in the classroom, talk to the kids, and listen to the staff. THAT is what defines a school!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s